There is nothing special about this recipe, it has been around forever and is in at least 4 of my old cookbooks, but it is so good that it is worth resurrecting. Every bit of it is laborious, from stirring in the milk to wrapping each candy into individual wrappers, but the end result is worth it!
4 cups of white Sugar
1 cup of Butter
2 cups of White Corn Syrup (like Karo Syrup)
1 teaspoon Salt
24 oz. Canned Evaporated Milk (2 – 12oz Cans)
1 teaspoon Vanilla Extract (added after candy stage is reached)
Melt the sugar, butter, corn syrup and salt in a large pot. Once it comes to a boil, slowly drizzle in the evaporated milk, stirring constantly. Do this slowly enough that it takes about 15 minutes PER CAN. To get a time reference, I used a 1 ounce measuring glass and counted to 60 as I poured. It is truly just a drizzle so that the milk doesn’t curdle and separate. After all the milk is added, bring the mixture to soft ball stage (238 degrees F) using a candy thermometer. 238 degrees will produce a soft caramel, 240 degrees will be slightly chewy and anything more than that will have the hard, sucker-like consistency of a Sugar Daddy. All of them are good, it just depends on what you want. Once at temperature, immediately remove from heat and stir in the Vanilla extract. Pour into a 9 x 13 parchment lined pan and allow to cool before cutting. Wrap individual pieces in wax paper and keep in an airtight jar. Refrigerating them will make them last longer, but they will be harder the colder they are.